A Business Intellectual?
Administrator
I have always wanted to be a scholar and a businessman. In some way, this is an oxymoron - and if you look at it, few have been able to bridge the difference that it entails.
According to ” the American Political Tradition: and the Men who Made it” which was written by Richard Hofstadter, American business people are rarely men or women who were thought leaders. Business people have more traditionally been oriented toward action rather than contemplation. Business people can often be highly intelligent, but what makes them successful is the excellence of mind that is employed within a fairly narrow, immediate and predictable range:
Whereas the mind of the intellectual not only wants to work with ideas, but also to play with them. Thus, ideas for an intellectualhave an integrity of their own, and the intellecutal
approaches them therefore with’piety’, while the business executive lives off ideas, not for them.”
To a certain degree, therefore, it is hard to be an intellectual businessman. In my personal sense, I do sense that - sometimes, I tend to think ” too much”, or analyze too much, or tinker too much, rather than let it be. And that can sometimes not be too good for business….
What do you think?
del.icio.us Digg it reddit StumbleUpon
Posted in FrontPage, on Business |




February 5th, 2007 at 9:57 pm
I think this is tough. As someone who loves to read about new ideas, I find that I am sometimes ahead of the curve in business, and that success comes from being more mainstream and pragmatic.
February 6th, 2007 at 12:23 am
Intellectuals think. Business people execute - and most of all -apply.
A business person can moonlight to become an intellectual, given the right environment and motivation. On the other, it would be extremely difficult for the intellectual to do the reverse..
My two cents worth..
February 6th, 2007 at 7:39 am
thanks. These are valuable insights!
February 8th, 2007 at 2:26 am
Profitable businesses come from a middle ground. I think it’s a balance between intellect and business savvy that enables one to be successful. Too much though and not enough drive (or attention to the bottom line) can make any great idea fail.